Stardew Valley: Abigail's Parenthood Controversy, Explained
Stardew Valley characters have complicated relationships with each other that you'll get to explore as you earn friendship points with them. One of the most interesting ones, though, you'll need to piece together on your own.
RELATED: How To Win The Stardew Valley Fair Grange Display Contest
As the game goes on, you may feel as though not everything is perfect in Abigail's family. Things just aren't adding up. Here, we're explaining everything you need to know about what's hiding underneath the surface.
Updated January 17, 2022: In order to dive even further into Abigail's history, we've added a video guide to help explain what exactly is going on in her corner of Pelican Town.
Whatever you suspect based on conversations with other characters, the crux of the theory is a line of dialogue you can receive when talking to the Wizard. You must have ten hearts of friendship with him before he will say it, though.
He admits that he thinks one of the locals is his daughter, and that you musn't say anything about it to anyone. Obviously, speculation about who it could be began immediately.
RELATED: The Best Games That Let You Get Married
The root of the theory centers around a few particular lines of dialogue that Caroline and Pierre say once you reach at least 8 hearts of friendship with them:
Some other dialogue hints at trouble in paradise for Pierre and Caroline.
One line of Caroline's just cements Abigail's oddness.
Pierre and Abigail also don't get along very well, as seen in their heart events.
RELATED: The Best Stardew Valley Farm Layouts
One major clue is Abigail's hair color. It's the exact same shade of purple as the Wizard's! While dialogue lines from Abigail and Caroline indicate that Abigail once dyed her hair, and
Read more on thegamer.com
