In , the defining ability of the paladin class is their sacred oaths. There is one paladin companion in the game, Minthara, who follows the Oath of Vengeance.
Even if the party is going to betray her, one universal way for a paladin player character to break their paladin oaths is to reveal the location of the Emerald Grove to Minthara in Act 1.
However, since Minthara as a non-companion is a crucial part of this quest, some players may wonder if Minthara can break her Oath.
Minthara is only recruitable past Act 1, and she obviously can't be part of the party while raiding the grove. Despite the player character breaking their own oath by siding with her, when she is encountered again in Act 2, she will still be a Vengeance paladin.
A paladin's oath is core to their character, so a main character breaking theirs would be rather significant. With that being said, is Minthara able to become an Oathbreaker?